Non-Grant Capital FAQs
These questions offer guidance to funders trying to understand non-grant capital, select the right tools, and determine when and how to use them. Non-grant capital offers funders additional ways to support their partners, share financial risk, mobilize other sources of funding, and help build independence for long-term growth.
-
Non-grant capital refers to grant funding that offers different financing mechanisms than traditional grants. These approaches may include recoverable grants, recyclable grants, forgivable or low interest loans, guarantees, or outcomes based funding.
The primary difference is that traditional grants generally do not require repayment, while many non-grant instruments include some form of repayment, recovery, or risk-sharing.
Non-grant capital does not require a profit-making entity. A foundation might provide a zero-interest loan, for example, or make funding recoverable only if an organization reaches a specified financial milestone.
The objective is not to replace grants but to match the financing structure to the needs of the recipient, which building more independence and long term sustainability from future funding.
More information here.
-
Providing Non-grant capital options to partners can help funders:
Address financing gaps that grants alone may not solve.
Support partners in more creative, flexible ways.
Support organizations as they grow or develop new revenue sources.
Recycle recovered funds into future activities.
Share risk with other funders and investors.
Make funding go farther.
Help build more funding independence among their partners (ie less dependence on traditional grants).
-
There is a wide variety of non-grant tools available. You can review the full list in this resource.
Below are a few examples:
Recoverable grant: A grant with an agreement that some or all funds will be repaid if a specified event occurs, such as reaching a program or fundraising milestone. If these events do not occur, repayment may not be required by the donor.
Recyclable grant: A grant structured so that returned or recovered funds can be reused to support other work. Similar to recoverable grants. The term“recyclable” describes the reuse of funds rather than a different type of product.
Forgivable loan: Grant structured as a loan where repayment may be reduced or canceled when certain conditions are met, such as achieving impact milestones or meeting program requirements.
Low-interest loan: A grant structured as a loan with an interest rate offered below market rates, often with flexible terms or longer repayment periods, to make financing more affordable for a mission-driven partner.
Outcomes-based financing: Funding in which payments depend on agreed upon results from the program or project. The structure of the payments is negotiated up front upon agreeing to the funding format.
Guarantee: A commitment to cover an agreed portion of an organization’s financial obligation to another funder under certain conditions. Can help unlock certain funding that would otherwise be unavailable.
First-loss capital: Capital positioned to absorb initial losses in a transaction or fund, protecting other funders up to an agreed amount and potentially attracting additional funding.
-
Non-grant capital refers broadly to financing instruments that philanthropic funders can use with grant funding. The goal is to provide a funding mechanism that supports grantee partners’ funding needs, delivers on the joint mission and builds independence and sustainability within the work itself.
Impact investing involves investing with the intention of generating positive, measurable social or environmental impact alongside a financial return.
Blended finance uses impact investment type approaches together with philanthropic capital to for development objectives.
Catalytic capital is financing that accepts disproportionate risk, lower returns, greater flexibility, or longer time horizons to enable impact that might otherwise not occur. There is still an assumption that this capital is repaid at some stage.
A foundation might use catalytic capital through a concessional loan or first-loss investment. That investment could also be part of a blended finance arrangement.
Understanding the distinctions helps funders communicate with their partners around their funding and programmatic objectives and choose suitable structures accordingly.
-
For U.S. private foundations, program-related investments (PRIs) are investments made primarily to accomplish charitable purposes, with producing income or appreciating property not being a significant purpose.
PRIs can take different forms, including loans, equity investments, and certain guarantees. Qualifying PRIs generally count toward a private foundation's minimum distribution requirement. They are typically dispersed as a separate transaction than grants.
Mission-related investments (MRIs) are investments selected partly or wholly for their alignment with a foundation's mission. They are generally made from investment assets and are subject to applicable investment standards.
Unlike PRIs, MRIs are not a distinct federal tax classification.
Non-grant capital is a grant product intended to support a programmatic partner with a unique funding mechanism alongside traditional grants.
A foundation should determine which approach fits its charitable objectives, financial expectations, governance, and regulatory obligations.
-
Start with the problem the funding is intended to solve.
A traditional grant is often the best option when activities generate significant social value but have no realistic repayment source. Examples include advocacy, community organizing, humanitarian assistance, and essential services for underserved populations.
Non-grant capital may be appropriate when an organization has identifiable future revenues, needs financing for an asset, or could benefit from a structure that shares financial risk.
Funders should ask:
What does the recipient actually need?
Is there a credible source of repayment?
Would repayment obligations create additional pressure?
Does the alternative structure improve the likely impact?
Would using non-grant capital help build independence and sustainability for our partner?
If non-grant capital adds complexity without improving outcomes, a grant may be preferable.
-
The right instrument depends on the recipient's financial circumstances, the intended use of funds, the expectation for recovered funds, and the funder's risk tolerance.
A recoverable grant may be appropriate when future financial success is uncertain and repayment should depend on specific conditions.
A loan may work when the recipient has reasonably predictable cash flow and can manage scheduled repayments.
A guarantee may help when an external lender is willing to provide financing but needs additional protection against risk.
Outcomes-based funding is useful when programmatic milestones help you negotiate a flexible agreement for repayment or programmatic delivery.
The starting point should always be the financing gap and programmatic needs of your partner, not the instrument a foundation is most interested in trying.
-
Yes. Combining grants with other financing instruments can be particularly effective when different components of a project have different financial characteristics.
For example, a foundation supporting a reusable packaging enterprise might provide:
A grant for community engagement and behavior-change activities.
A concessional loan for reusable containers and washing equipment.
A guarantee to help the enterprise obtain additional working capital.
Each instrument addresses a distinct need.
Funders should clearly document the purpose, conditions, reporting obligations, and financial expectations associated with each component in the grant agreement, but a singular transaction incorporating all of these mechanisms is possible.
-
Nonprofits can receive non-grant capital. Their legal status does not automatically determine which financing instruments are available.
A nonprofit might receive a loan to purchase equipment, bridge a confirmed payment obligation, or finance an activity with predictable earned income.
However, the organization needs an appropriate repayment source if the financing requires repayment.
Nonprofits should not be pressured to develop commercial revenue models simply to access new funding instruments.
Funders should evaluate financial capacity, organizational priorities, and whether the financing supports rather than undermines the recipient's mission.
-
Yes, in some circumstances, but it is important to distinguish the activity's social value from its ability to generate financial recovery.
Advocacy and community organizing, for example, often create public benefits without producing revenue. Traditional grants are generally well suited to these activities. But non-grant products could be designed by putting a value on the outcomes and using concessional loans or other similar mechanisms.
Other arrangements may be possible when a separate repayment source exists or when recovery is contingent on a future event.
For early-stage innovation, a recoverable grant could provide funding with recovery required only if commercialization or another defined milestone occurs.
The absence of revenue should never be treated as evidence that an activity lacks value.
-
Repayment terms should reflect the recipient's financial reality as well as contingencies.
Potential approaches include:
Repayment beginning only after a specified milestone.
Revenue-based repayments that fluctuate with certain activities.
Longer grace periods before repayment begins.
Recovery triggered by follow-on financing or commercialization.
Forgiveness or reduced repayment under clearly defined conditions.
-
The answer depends on what’s outlined in the grant agreement.
A recoverable grant may require repayment only if specified financial conditions occur. If those conditions are not met, the recipient may have no repayment obligation.
A loan generally creates an enforceable obligation, although its terms may permit deferral, restructuring, or forgiveness.
Funders should address potential repayment difficulties before providing financing.
The agreement should explain what happens if revenues fall short, milestones are delayed, or the organization experiences financial distress.
Clear expectations protect both the recipient and the funder.
Ultimately a philanthropic funder is not using these tools for financial returns. So lack of repayment should not be a negative consequence.
-
Philanthropic capital can sometimes make an opportunity more attractive to other funders or investors by addressing risks they are unwilling or unable to assume.
For example, a foundation might provide a guarantee to support organizations waiting on future payment from a government partner.
Alternatively, first-loss capital could absorb an agreed portion of potential losses, reducing exposure for other funders.
Grants can also finance early-stage development, technical assistance, or market-building activities that make later investment more feasible.
However, additional capital is not automatically beneficial. Funders should ensure that co-investment supports the intended impact and does not create inappropriate obligations for recipients.
-
If a philanthropic funder is concerned about returned capital, there may be a financial risk with using certain non-grant capital mechanisms.
Funders should also assess:
Mission risk: Financing incentives may shift attention away from the funder’s mission and vision.
Recipient risk: Repayment obligations may weaken financial stability.
Operational risk: The foundation may lack the capacity to structure and monitor transactions.
Legal and compliance risk: The arrangement may create unfamiliar regulatory obligations.
Reputational risk: Poorly designed financing may damage relationships or trust.
The objective is not to eliminate all risk. It is to understand which risks are acceptable, who bears them, and whether the anticipated impact justifies the arrangement.
-
Readiness involves more than a mechanism to pay back a recoverable or recyclable grant.
Funders should have the proper discussions with their partners, and agree together on all financial, programmatic and operational expectations before signing a grant agreement.
An organization may have a compelling opportunity but lack the financial systems needed to manage a loan.
In that situation, a grant for capacity-building or a different financing structure may be more appropriate.
-
Not necessarily.
A foundation may be able to test certain instruments using its existing structure, supported by external legal, financial, and transaction expertise.
Intermediaries can also help source opportunities, assess recipients, structure financing, and monitor investments.
However, foundations still need appropriate governance, internal accountability, and approval processes.
The capabilities required depend on the complexity and scale of the activities being considered.
A foundation testing one recoverable grant will generally have different operational needs from one managing a diversified investment portfolio.
Most of these structures can be easily written into a grant agreement as would a traditional grant.
-
Relevant capabilities may include:
Financial analysis.
Deal sourcing and recipient due diligence.
Financial structuring and negotiation.
Legal and regulatory compliance.
Contract development and management.
Portfolio monitoring and reporting.
Impact measurement.
Relationship management and communication.
Foundations should also clarify who identifies opportunities, who approves financing, who monitors performance, and who makes decisions when circumstances change.
Not every capability needs to be developed internally. External specialists and intermediaries can play important roles.
-
Begin by aligning leadership around the problem the foundation is trying to solve.
Rather than presenting non-grant capital as an entirely new investment strategy, identify specific situations where existing grantmaking may not fully meet partner needs.
Program teams can contribute knowledge of charitable objectives and recipients, while investment and finance teams bring expertise in financial risk and structuring.
A shared decision-making framework can help prevent internal silos from determining which instruments are available.
Starting with a limited pilot may also help leadership develop confidence before expanding into more complex arrangements.
More recommendations HERE.
-
In some circumstances, foundations can use resources otherwise designated for grantmaking to support recoverable grants or other charitable financing arrangements.
However, legal classification, accounting treatment, investment policies, and distribution requirements may affect how the funds can be used.
There is no universally appropriate percentage to allocate.
Foundations should consider the size of the opportunity, potential financial losses, organizational capacity, and implications for existing grant commitments.
A modest pilot allocation may be a more practical starting point than establishing a large dedicated pool of capital.
-
The agreement should clearly describe the purpose of the funding, the expectations of program delivery, permitted uses, financial obligations, and conditions governing repayment or recovery.
Depending on the instrument, it may also address:
Repayment triggers and schedules.
Interest or other financial returns.
Milestones and performance expectations.
Reporting requirements.
Circumstances permitting deferral, restructuring, or forgiveness.
Default provisions and dispute resolution.
Responsibilities of both parties.
Transparency is particularly important.
Funders should communicate these terms early, not only when presenting the final agreement.
-
A pilot should begin with a clearly identified funding gap and a specific programmatic objective.
The foundation should then determine whether a different instrument could address that gap more effectively than a traditional grant.
A practical pilot process includes:
Assessing internal readiness and leadership alignment.
Identifying a suitable partner or opportunity.
Selecting and structuring the instrument.
Establishing legal, financial, and impact safeguards.
Defining success measures and learning objectives.
Monitoring results and deciding whether to adapt or expand.
An intermediary may be helpful when the foundation lacks transaction experience or wants to test an approach without building a dedicated investment function.
Success should be evaluated through both financial performance and charitable outcomes.
-
One common mistake is starting with a non-grant capital instrument rather than exploring with your partner what the funding need is and what the programmatic expectations are.
Other mistakes include assuming every recipient should generate revenue, underestimating internal capacity requirements, introducing unnecessary repayment pressure, and failing to communicate terms clearly.
Foundations can avoid these problems by beginning with three practical actions:
First, assess organizational readiness. Understand leadership alignment, governance, available expertise, and risk tolerance.
Second, examine real financing scenarios. Identify where current funding approaches may be insufficient and compare possible instruments.
Third, establish a manageable pilot. Select an opportunity, allocate appropriate resources, and define what the foundation hopes to learn.
The goal is not to use as many financial instruments as possible. It is to make better funding decisions.
Try the Non-Grant Readiness Assessment to determine where you are ready, and where you might need some additional work!
Ready to Explore Non-Grant Capital?
Understanding the tools is only the beginning. The more important question is whether and how they fit with your organization's philanthropic approach.
Assess your readiness: Take the Non-Grant Capital Readiness Assessment.
Explore tools and other materials: Resources
This FAQ is intended for educational purposes and does not constitute legal, tax, accounting, or investment advice. Funders should consult qualified professionals regarding specific transactions and regulatory requirements.
© 2026 Joanne Sonenshine